CAN WE ASSIST YOU? WE ARE AVAILABLE 24/7 | 
CALL US: (812) 275-3389 | MAKE ARRANGEMENTS AND PAY ONLINE NOW
Tribute Wall
Thursday
24
October
Visitation
4:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Thursday, October 24, 2019
Day & Carter Mortuary
1133 Lincoln Ave.
Bedford, Indiana, United States
Friday
25
October
Funeral Service
11:00 am
Friday, October 25, 2019
Day & Carter Mortuary
1133 Lincoln Ave.
Bedford, Indiana, United States
Loading...
J
Joseph D. O'Connor posted a condolence
Tuesday, November 5, 2019
John,
Sorry to hear of your Dad's passing. I will remember him as a judge who projected his authority in the court and with counsel but was fair and considerate when called for. He was also a fierce advocate for his clients as I experienced several times while mediating his cases.
My condolences to you and your family.
Joe O'Connor
S
Susan Nelson posted a condolence
Tuesday, November 5, 2019
John and family—my sympathy for you loss. Liked and respected your dad as judge and colleague. Let me share 2 Judge Plummer anecdotes. 1. John Haury was defending an armed robbery case in Circuit court. I was holding his briefcase. For some reason, we had subpoenaed Dr. Benito Odulio, who,being a doctor, ignored the subpoena. When Haury informed the court of that, your dad said, “we will be in recess.” Got up. Went into his chambers and called sheriff, ordering them to go to doc’s office in Mitchell, arrest him, cuff him,put him back of squad car and haul him to court. (I got this from court reporter). When doc appears in scrubs and cuffs, Dad proceeds to rip him a new one. On the record. #2. Before there were CHINS, kids were adjudged “dependent and neglected “. Late,great Ruel Steele is representing the then Welfare Department. I am with Legal Services representing parents. Case worker testifying. Steele, in his gravelly voice, asks “So is this child dependent and neglected under the law of the State of Indiana?” I object. Class for legal conclusion. SUSTAINED. Steele says “But, your honor, I always ask that question.” Dad says, “Nobody ever objected before.”
T
Tessa posted a condolence
Sunday, November 3, 2019
John was such a nice neighbor! My dog and I loved greeting him as he was out with Hershey and Falcon. I am so sorry to his family. I lost a parent myself last year and this world is a very different place without a parent / grandparent. I wish you peace and comfort during this difficult time!
A
Ali Taylor lit a candle
Friday, October 25, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle4.png
A
Ali Taylor posted a condolence
Friday, October 25, 2019
So sorry to hear of John's passing. My sympathies go out to his family and friends.
Sincerely,
Ali Taylor, cousin from NYC
P
Peggy Buck lit a candle
Thursday, October 24, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle4.png
My prayers and sympathy for the families of John-Plummer.
Peggy Buckçj
S
Susanne Borchers lit a candle
Thursday, October 24, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle9.png
Susanne Borchers geb. Oberschmidt und husband Kay Borchers
W
William And Cathy Hawkins lit a candle
Thursday, October 24, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
With heartfelt condolences.
Bill & Cathy Hawkins
W
William And Cathy Hawkins posted a condolence
Thursday, October 24, 2019
John treated us like friends in the office. His advice and direction served the client. His services were always fair and concise. We will miss him!
E
Eddie & Sharon Knight lit a candle
Thursday, October 24, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
B
Bob & Donna Skeen posted a condolence
Thursday, October 24, 2019
so sorry to hear of johns passing. he had become a friend and had been given good advice. A big lose to Bedford. Prayers for all the family.
K
Karen Harp Rodgers lit a candle
Wednesday, October 23, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle4.png
My condolences to John's family and friends. I was a member of the 1960 BHS class. John was always a great friend of everyone.
D
David Oberschmidt lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
Dear Uncle John, I’m glad we could spend summers together when I was young. You will be missed and you will never be forgotten. David
S
Sophia Frazier lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle4.png
I offer my sympathies to the family upon his passing.
S
Shirley Guzman posted a condolence
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
I feel great sadness at hearing of my great neighbor John passing away. I saw John last week walking his little dogs. He will be missed in our neighborhood here at Eagle Pointe. So sorry for his family.
J
J. D. Woods posted a condolence
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
In the late 1950's the Woods family moved into the old two-story house on the corner of 12th and M streets in Bedford, just two doors down from where John lived with his mom, grandmother, sister Carol and little brother, Bill who was my age. Bill and I had good times together growing up. But one of my few memories of John was that while he could be deadly serious on occasion, he also had an infectious grin that was warm and inviting. Kid brothers and their friends can be exceptionally annoying to older siblings, and no doubt Bill and I probably annoyed older brother John. But in my few encounters, I never remembered him being rough or impatient with us. Rather, his good nature and ready laugh gave me a comforting sense of well-being. Even at that young age, I somehow knew John was destined for greatness at whatever he would do in this world. I never had a big brother, but if I did, I would have wanted him to be just like John Plummer.
J. D. Woods
B
Bill & Nancy Cowden lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
Jennifer and Family, We are so sorry for your loss. Prayers for all.
F
Fred Hostettler posted a condolence
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
I can’t believe Johnny’s gone. From age 8 we grew up together. He was unique. Highly intelligent, sometimes impulsive he could discuss history as well as whether Juan Marichal was a better pitcher than Bob Gibson. Goodby Sandy John. I know Booc was there to greet you. See you soon. Fred
T
Tom Johnson posted a condolence
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
I knew John from the first grade on at old Central Elementary. He loved his family and his country and John was quite an athlete. As a Dodger fan, I regret that John was a staunch Giants fan. God bless you John.
B
Bob & Susan Wykoff lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle5.png
Sorry for your loss-Bob & Susan Wykoff
C
Carol Oberschmidt lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle3.png
Carol and Thomas Oberschmidt
C
Carol Oberschmidt posted a condolence
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
In my last phone call to him just three days before his death, my brother John told me how proud he was of his children and grandchildren. Above all, he cherished his family, friends, and community.
M
Mariane and Jan R Buker lit a candle
Tuesday, October 22, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle4.png
John was a good man and will be missed. May God draw close to his family in this time of loss.
J
Judge Nikirk posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
John was a wonderful man and excellent attorney. I am so thankful I was able know him.
W
Walter Glover posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
Prayers and condolence. John was one of my bro's favs. God bless. Walter Glover
N
Nicol Sargent posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
So many fun times with John at the LCC and Elks. He was a great man and I am much better for having known him. He was a great advocate for the people of Lawrence County. Rest In Peace John. Prayers and sympathy to his family.
J
John Potter posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
It was just a few weeks ago I saw John while in the courthouse annex. We talked for a few minutes. Glad I had that chance. He was a great attorney, and a true gentleman. We will miss him.
D
Debby & Tony Dobson lit a candle
Monday, October 21, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
D
Debby & Tony Dobson posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
To John's Family,
So Sorry for your loss.John was a great attorney .We sure will miss him.Our thoughts & Prayers are with you!
S
Sara Daulton lit a candle
Monday, October 21, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle2.png
K
Kevin & Jessica Allen lit a candle
Monday, October 21, 2019
//s3.amazonaws.com/skins.funeraltechweb.com/tribute-gestures/Candle.png
S
Stan and April Glenn posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
So sorry to hear of Johns passing. Have been friends for years. He was a kind man.
J
John Drier posted a condolence
Monday, October 21, 2019
John was an icon of the legal community of Lawrence County. He was a real gentleman and a zealous advocate, and will be missed. I'm sure over the long term of his legal career he helped thousands in the community.
J
The family of John Maurice Plummer, Jr. uploaded a photo
Monday, October 21, 2019
/tribute-images/1155/Ultra/John-Plummer-Jr.jpg
Please wait
Home | About Us | Testimonials | Pre-Need | Obituaries
.
1133 Lincoln Avenue | Bedford, Indiana 47421 | Phone: (812) 275-3389 | Fax: (812) 275-7025